AWX: Beyond the Green – A Deep Dive into Diversified Operations and Undervalued Assets - AWX Stock Research Report

## Executive Summary / Key Takeaways * Dual-Engine Business Model: Avalon Holdings Corporation (AWX) operates a unique, diversified model spanning specialized waste management services and an integrated resort and golf hospitality portfolio, offering distinct revenue streams and market exposures. * Operational Resilience Amidst Headwinds: Despite recent revenue declines in Q2 and the first half of 2025, primarily due to a slowdown in "event work" in waste management and adverse weather impacting golf operations, the company demonstrated improved gross margins in its waste segment and strategic investments in its hospitality assets. * High-Stakes Legal Battle: The protracted suspension of AWX's saltwater injection wells, embroiled in ongoing litigation with oral arguments scheduled for August 20, 2025, represents both a significant operational drag and a potential catalyst for future value if resolved favorably. * Strategic Capital Deployment: AWX is actively investing in its hospitality segment, with $9.0 million in restricted cash earmarked for renovations at The Grand Resort, signaling a commitment to enhancing its leisure offerings and driving future membership and room rental growth. * Value Proposition & Competitive Dynamics: AWX operates as a niche player, leveraging specialized service delivery and integrated experiences to compete against larger, more diversified industry giants. Its current valuation metrics (P/S of 0.12, P/B of 0.26) suggest potential undervaluation compared to industry peers, warranting a closer look. ## Unpacking Avalon's Dual Identity in a Dynamic Landscape Avalon Holdings Corporation (NYSE American: AWX) presents a compelling, albeit complex, investment narrative, rooted in its distinctive dual business model. Since its spin-off from American Waste Services in 1998, AWX has cultivated a diversified portfolio, balancing the steady, essential services of waste management with the more cyclical, experience-driven world of resort hospitality and golf. This unique structure positions Avalon as a niche player, strategically carving out value in two disparate, yet complementary, sectors. The waste management services segment provides hazardous and nonhazardous waste brokerage and management, captive landfill management, and, historically, saltwater injection well operations. This segment thrives on specialized expertise and tailored solutions for industrial, commercial, municipal, and governmental clients across the northeastern and midwestern U.S. In contrast, the golf and related operations segment encompasses a comprehensive hospitality offering, including The Grand Resort hotel, four golf courses, country clubs, and a multipurpose recreation center, providing a self-contained vacation experience and a robust membership model. AWX's competitive positioning is defined by its ability to offer specialized, "turnkey" services in waste management, differentiating itself from larger, more generalized players like Waste Management Inc. (TICKER:WM) and Republic Services (TICKER:RSG). While these industry giants benefit from immense scale, extensive networks, and often superior technological infrastructure for broad-spectrum waste handling, Avalon focuses on agility and customized solutions. For instance, its waste brokerage model, which identifies cost-efficient disposal options and centralizes services to minimize procurement costs for clients, represents a key operational differentiator. This approach, while not "technology" in the traditional sense of a patented product, is a sophisticated service delivery model that provides tangible benefits: enhanced customer loyalty, potentially higher margins in niche markets, and the ability to compete effectively by exploiting the less flexible aspects of larger competitors. Similarly, in its hospitality segment, the integrated resort experience, combining golf, dining, spa services, and lodging, acts as a "technological moat" by offering a cohesive value proposition that aims to drive membership and repeat business. However, this niche positioning also comes with inherent vulnerabilities. AWX's smaller scale and customer concentration, particularly in its captive landfill management business which relies on a single customer, expose it to greater risk compared to the diversified revenue streams of its larger counterparts. The company's financial metrics, such as a TTM Gross Profit Margin of 18.72% and Operating Profit Margin of 2.22%, generally lag behind the more robust figures of WM (29% Gross, 19% Operating) and RSG (42% Gross, 20% Operating), reflecting the scale advantages enjoyed by these industry leaders. Yet, AWX's lower Debt/Equity ratio of 0.94 compared to WM's 2.90 or RSG's 1.14 suggests a more conservative capital structure, which can be a strength in volatile markets.

Loading interactive chart...

## The Waste Management Engine: Navigating Event Work Volatility Avalon's waste management services segment is the company's foundational revenue generator, providing essential services that underpin industrial and municipal operations. In the second quarter of 2025, this segment reported net operating revenues of $9.7 million, a notable decrease from $12.2 million in the same period last year. This 20.3% decline was primarily attributed to a reduction in "event work projects"—one-time, bid-based contracts that can fluctuate significantly. For the first six months of 2025, the trend continued, with revenues falling to $19.4 million from $24.7 million, a 21.3% decrease, again largely due to a $5.1 million drop in event work. Despite the revenue contraction, the segment demonstrated an improvement in profitability, with the overall gross margin percentage for waste brokerage and management services increasing to 23.0% in Q2 2025 from 22.0% in Q2 2024. This marginal improvement was attributed to higher gross profit generated from the event work projects that were undertaken. Income before income taxes for the segment, however, decreased to $1.0 million in Q2 2025 from $1.3 million in Q2 2024, reflecting the overall revenue decline. The captive landfill management operations provided a bright spot, showing an 8.9% increase in revenue for Q2 2025 to $0.85 million, and a 19.7% increase for the six-month period to $1.76 million, underscoring the stability of its single-customer dependence. A critical, long-standing challenge for this segment remains the suspension of its saltwater injection wells. Since August 2014, operations for the AWMS 2.00 well have been halted due to seismic activity concerns, leading to a protracted legal battle. Avalon has consistently appealed regulatory decisions, with the Supreme Court of Ohio ruling in its favor on multiple occasions, only to face further appeals and remands from lower courts. Oral arguments for the latest appeal to the Supreme Court of Ohio are scheduled for August 20, 2025. This ongoing legal saga has resulted in consistent losses for the injection well operations, primarily from legal and professional costs, and represents a significant unrealized asset and a drain on resources. A favorable resolution could unlock substantial value, but the uncertainty persists. ## The Hospitality & Leisure Portfolio: Investing in Experience Avalon's golf and related operations segment, centered around The Grand Resort and its associated country clubs, offers a different dimension to the company's investment profile. This segment, designed to provide an integrated leisure experience, faced headwinds in the second quarter and first half of 2025. Net operating revenues decreased to $10.5 million in Q2 2025 from $10.8 million in Q2 2024, a 3.0% decline. For the six-month period, revenues were $16.9 million, down from $17.2 million, a 1.9% decrease. The primary culprit for this downturn was adverse weather conditions, which impacted business activity across The Grand Resort and country clubs. This led to a 5.9% decrease in food, beverage, and merchandise sales in Q2 2025, and a 9.4% drop in greens fees and cart rentals due to fewer rounds played. Membership dues revenue also saw a 4.0% decrease for the six-month period, reflecting a reduction in members—a key metric for this segment's long-term health. Room rental revenue, however, showed resilience, increasing by 1.9% for the six-month period, driven by higher average room rates, even as Q2 occupancy saw a slight dip. The "other revenues" category, encompassing athletic, fitness, salon, dermatology, and spa services, demonstrated growth, increasing by 6.9% in Q2 2025 and 3.6% for the six-month period, highlighting the value of diversified offerings within the resort. Despite the revenue challenges, operating costs for the segment increased, primarily due to higher utility and general operating expenditures. This, coupled with the revenue decline, resulted in a significant drop in profitability, with income before income taxes falling to $0.6 million in Q2 2025 from $1.0 million in Q2 2024. For the six-month period, the segment reported a net loss before income taxes of $0.71 million, a substantial increase from a $0.013 million loss in the prior year. Strategically, Avalon is committed to enhancing this segment. The 2022 Term Loan Agreement included $10.4 million in proceeds specifically for renovating and expanding The Grand Resort and Avalon Field Club at New Castle, with $9.0 million in restricted cash still held for these projects. This capital deployment underscores management's belief in the long-term potential of its integrated resort model to attract and retain members, a critical factor for future growth. ## Financial Health and Capital Allocation Avalon's consolidated financial performance in the first half of 2025 reflects the segment-specific challenges. Total net operating revenues decreased to $36.3 million for the six months ended June 30, 2025, from $41.9 million in the prior year. This led to a net loss attributable to Avalon Holdings Corporation common shareholders of $1.2 million, a significant increase from a $0.025 million loss in the first six months of 2024. Basic and diluted net loss per share stood at $0.31, compared to $0.01 in the prior year.

Loading interactive chart...

On the liquidity front, Avalon utilized existing cash and cash provided by operations to meet its needs. Cash and cash equivalents increased to $3.7 million at June 30, 2025, from $2.8 million at December 31, 2024. The company maintains a $5.0 million line of credit with Wesbanco Bank, which was extended to July 2026, with $1.8 million available as of June 30, 2025. This provides a crucial buffer for operational flexibility.

Loading interactive chart...

The company's working capital position, however, saw a deficit of $1.7 million at June 30, 2025, an increase from a $0.9 million deficit at year-end 2024. This was primarily driven by an increase in deferred membership dues revenue, accounts payable, and accrued payroll, partially offset by increases in cash, accounts receivable, and inventory. Management anticipates that cash generated from future operations will be sufficient to meet operating requirements and debt obligations, and the line of credit remains available if additional funds are needed. Capital expenditures for 2025 are projected to be in the range of $2.5 million to $3.5 million, primarily allocated to hotel room remodeling at The Grand Resort, building improvements, and equipment purchases. These investments are expected to be funded by the dedicated project fund account and cash generated from operations, signaling a strategic focus on enhancing the hospitality segment's infrastructure and guest experience.

Loading interactive chart...

## Risks and the Path Forward Investing in AWX involves a careful consideration of several key risks. The most prominent is the ongoing legal battle surrounding the saltwater injection wells. The protracted nature of this dispute, coupled with the potential for increased regulatory scrutiny and environmental event risks, creates significant uncertainty. While Avalon asserts its property rights, the continued suspension and associated legal costs weigh on the waste management segment's profitability and overall company performance. Economic conditions, including inflation and potential recessionary pressures, pose a substantial risk, particularly to the discretionary spending-dependent golf and related operations segment. As consumers tighten their belts, membership retention and new sales, room occupancy, and F&B sales could face further pressure. Labor challenges, including the ability to recruit and retain qualified personnel in a competitive market, also threaten operating margins across both segments, especially for the specialized expertise required in waste management. Furthermore, a significant portion of Avalon's waste brokerage business operates without long-term contracts, exposing it to customer churn and competitive pressures. The dependence of the captive landfill management business on a single customer also represents a concentration risk. In the golf segment, the ability to attract and retain members is paramount, and a significant decline could adversely affect financial results. Despite these challenges, Avalon's strategic initiatives, particularly the ongoing investment in The Grand Resort, aim to strengthen its hospitality offerings. The company's niche focus in waste management, emphasizing tailored solutions and operational flexibility, positions it to compete effectively in specific market segments. The resolution of the saltwater injection well dispute, while uncertain, could unlock a valuable asset and significantly improve the company's financial outlook. ## Conclusion Avalon Holdings Corporation stands at a critical juncture, balancing the steady, if sometimes volatile, operations of its waste management segment with the growth potential and investment needs of its hospitality portfolio. The recent financial performance, marked by revenue declines and increased losses in the first half of 2025, highlights the impact of external factors like weather and the inherent lumpiness of "event work" projects. Yet, the underlying operational improvements in waste management margins and strategic capital allocation towards the Grand Resort underscore a management team actively working to enhance long-term value. For discerning investors, AWX represents a unique opportunity to invest in a diversified, niche-oriented company that appears significantly undervalued relative to its book value and sales compared to its larger, publicly traded peers. The ongoing legal battle over the saltwater injection wells remains a pivotal factor, carrying both substantial risk and the potential for a significant re-rating upon a favorable resolution. The company's commitment to enhancing its resort experience through capital expenditures, coupled with its specialized approach in waste management, forms the core of its investment thesis. Monitoring the progress of the legal proceedings, the effectiveness of hospitality investments in driving membership and occupancy, and the ability to manage operating costs will be crucial indicators for Avalon's path to unlocking its inherent value.