Executive Summary / Key Takeaways

• Robust Profitability and Diversified Earnings: The Hanover Insurance Group (THG) has demonstrated exceptional financial performance, achieving a record operating return on equity over 21% in Q3 2025 and a 19.1% operating ROE year-to-date, driven by strong underwriting, higher net investment income, and a strategically diversified portfolio across Personal Lines, Core Commercial, and Specialty segments.
• Technological Innovation as a Core Differentiator: THG is leveraging advanced technologies, including AI-powered underwriting tools, workflow automation, and the "TAP Sales" platform, to enhance efficiency, accelerate processing times, and improve agent and customer experience, creating a competitive moat in an evolving industry.
• Strategic Portfolio Repositioning and Growth Acceleration: Significant actions in Personal Lines (geographic rebalancing, deductible changes) and Core Commercial (underwriting adjustments) have substantially improved underlying profitability and mitigated catastrophe exposure, positioning the company for accelerating, profitable growth in targeted segments and diversification states.
• Prudent Capital Management and Strong Balance Sheet: With a strong reserve position, a high-quality investment portfolio (95% investment grade, A+ weighted average rating), and active share repurchase programs, THG maintains robust liquidity and capital flexibility, supporting shareholder returns and resilience against market volatility.
• Outlook for Continued Margin Expansion: Management's 2025 guidance projects continued improvement, with net written premium growth of 6-7%, a 12-14% increase in net investment income, and an ex-CAT combined ratio of 88.5-89.5%, reflecting confidence in sustained pricing discipline, operational efficiencies, and the benefits of its strategic initiatives.

A Foundation of Resilience: Hanover's Strategic Evolution and Technological Edge

The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. (NYSE:THG), founded in 1852 and headquartered in Worcester, Massachusetts, has established itself as a formidable player in the U.S. property and casualty (P&C) insurance market. The company's enduring strategy centers on profitable growth through a select independent agency distribution channel, aiming to expand its footprint in underpenetrated geographies and bolster its capabilities in specialty markets. This approach has fostered a diversified portfolio and broad-based profitability, underpinning its resilience in an increasingly complex industry landscape.

THG's historical journey includes strategic de-risking, such as the complete transfer of its Excess and Casualty Reinsurance Association (ECRA) liabilities in Q2 2025, a move that fully relieved its obligations to policyholders without materially impacting financial results. More recently, the company has undertaken significant portfolio enhancements, including a cumulative 47% increase in written renewal pricing in homeowners and 29% in core commercial property over the two years prior to 2024. In 2024, THG strategically reduced its Personal Lines policy count in the Midwest by 10.2% and implemented enhanced deductibles across most of its Personal Lines book to mitigate catastrophe exposure. These actions have had a tangible positive effect on performance and are expected to drive benefits into 2025 and beyond.

The P&C insurance industry is currently characterized by increasing risks, stable to rising loss trends, deteriorating liability trends, and persistent weather challenges. Against this backdrop, THG's differentiated technology stands out as a critical competitive advantage. The company has made substantial investments in data, analytics, and AI capabilities, developing effective quote buying and rating platforms known as "TAP Sales" for its Personal, Small Commercial, and relevant Specialty segments. These platforms streamline the quoting process, allowing agents to generate quotes in as few as 8 keystrokes and under 2 minutes for many customers, significantly enhancing efficiency, accuracy, and agent satisfaction.

Furthermore, THG is leveraging generative AI and AI capabilities to automate account submission ingestion, build triage functionality, and streamline workflow automation. In its E&S segment, a new AI-powered underwriting tool is being fine-tuned to streamline submission intake and triage, accelerating processing times and improving service levels. This modular architecture is designed for future scalability, extending to middle market, marine, other specialty lines, and even claims over time. The company has also integrated sensor technology in targeted Core Commercial properties, preventing millions of dollars in potential water and freeze losses. Its updated claims system, enhanced with third-party data and advanced "jumper severity escalation models," improves the ability to predict and manage claims, while virtual appraisals handle approximately 80% of auto physical damage claims, boosting efficiency and customer satisfaction. These technological differentiators contribute directly to THG's competitive moat, driving operational efficiency, supporting better underwriting decisions, and enhancing the overall agent and customer experience, thereby contributing to stronger financial performance and market positioning.

Competitive Positioning in a Dynamic Market

THG operates in a competitive landscape alongside major P&C insurers such as Progressive Corporation (PGR), The Travelers Companies, Inc. (TRV), Chubb Limited (CB), and Allstate Corporation (ALL). THG's strategic focus on the small to lower-end of the middle market, coupled with its strong independent agency network, provides a distinct competitive advantage. This segment is generally associated with lower cycle volatility and more resilient pricing compared to the larger account space, where competition is often more pronounced.

Compared to Progressive (PGR), known for its technology-driven personal auto focus, THG offers a more balanced portfolio across commercial and personal lines, potentially providing greater diversification. While Progressive excels in digital customer acquisition and pricing efficiency, THG's agent-based model fosters stronger customer loyalty, particularly in commercial segments, and its specialized offerings can differentiate it. THG's diversified risk management across segments allows for stable cash flow, whereas Progressive's auto-centric exposure can be more volatile.

Against The Travelers Companies (TRV), a major player in both commercial and personal lines, THG's agent-based distribution provides a localized market presence and tailored services. Travelers' broader scale offers extensive resources, but THG's niche commercial offerings and specialized coverages can lead to better customer retention. THG's operational execution and financial stability are solid, though Travelers' scale might enable stronger margins and cash flow.

When compared to Chubb Limited (CB), a global insurer with a strong emphasis on high-net-worth and commercial clients, THG's U.S.-focused, agent-driven operations offer a community-oriented approach. While Chubb's global reach and expertise in professional liability are significant, THG's specialized U.S. P&C focus can cultivate stronger domestic customer loyalty. THG's portfolio, skewed towards the middle market and smaller accounts, is less susceptible to the pricing pressures seen in the upper echelons where Chubb often competes.

Allstate Corporation (ALL), another prominent insurer with a mix of personal and commercial products, competes directly with THG in personal auto and homeowners. THG's independent agent model offers customized services, while Allstate's direct marketing excels in customer acquisition. THG's emphasis on independent brokers for commercial lines provides better penetration in that segment, offering a different value proposition than Allstate's consumer-facing innovations.

THG's competitive advantages, or "moats," include its strong brand in P&C insurance, extensive network of independent agents, and diversified product lines. These assets translate into enhanced customer loyalty, recurring revenue, and superior margins. The company's diversified product lines provide strategic adaptability, allowing it to exploit weaknesses in competitors' specialized areas and enhance growth. While THG faces vulnerabilities from catastrophe exposure and potential technological gaps compared to digitally advanced rivals, its proactive investments in AI and workflow automation are designed to bridge these gaps and enhance its competitive standing. The company's ability to offer a breadth of healthy products and streamline agent interactions, particularly for smaller, more transactional accounts, further strengthens its position in a consolidating agency market.

Financial Performance and Operational Momentum

The Hanover Insurance Group has delivered a strong financial performance, reflecting the effectiveness of its strategic initiatives and operational discipline. For the nine months ended September 30, 2025, net income improved significantly by $205.9 million to $464 million, driven primarily by higher after-tax operating income. Operating income before interest expense and income taxes surged by $248.3 million to $644 million for the same period. This impressive increase was attributed to lower catastrophe losses, improved current accident year underwriting results, particularly in Personal Lines, higher net investment income, and robust earned premium growth.

The third quarter of 2025 alone saw record operating earnings per share of $5.09 and a combined ratio of 91.1%. The combined ratio, excluding catastrophes, improved by 0.2 points from the prior year quarter, reaching 88.1%, primarily due to Personal Lines improvements. Catastrophe losses in Q3 2025 were $46.2 million, or 3.0 points of the combined ratio, coming in 3.8 points below the company's assumption and lower than historical averages, partly due to benign weather and effective property management actions. Net favorable development on prior years' loss reserves for the nine months ended September 30, 2025, increased by $8.5 million to $50.3 million, with modest favorability across all segments.

Segment-Specific Performance:

• Personal Lines: This segment posted an outstanding Q3 2025 current accident year ex-CAT combined ratio of 85.8%, an improvement of 3.4 points from the prior year. This was primarily driven by strong improvements in homeowners, where the ex-CAT current accident year loss ratio improved by 8.5 points to 47.2% due to strong earned pricing and lower attritional loss frequency. Personal Auto's ex-CAT current accident year loss ratio improved by 0.7 points to 69.1%, benefiting from earned pricing and favorable loss frequency, particularly in collision. Net premiums written for the nine months ended September 30, 2025, increased by 3.4% to $1,966.90 million. The rate of policies in force (PIF) decline has slowed significantly, with sequential PIF growth observed in diversification states.
• Core Commercial: Net premiums written for the nine months ended September 30, 2025, increased by 3.9% to $1,760.90 million. However, operating income before interest expense and income taxes decreased by 16.5% to $175.80 million, primarily due to higher current accident year losses and catastrophe losses, partially offset by increased net investment income. The Q3 2025 current accident year ex-CAT combined ratio was 94.3%, 2.5 points above the prior year, driven by increased severity in commercial auto and a couple of larger workers' comp claims. Management continues to prudently increase picks in commercial auto in response to increased severity.
• Specialty: This segment saw its net premiums written increase by 6.1% to $1,105.70 million for the nine months ended September 30, 2025. Operating income before interest expense and income taxes rose by 22.7% to $214.00 million, driven by higher net favorable development on prior year loss reserves, increased net investment income, and earned premium growth. The Q3 2025 current accident year ex-CAT combined ratio was 86%, with a loss ratio ex-CAT of 48.8%, outperforming the long-term expectation of low 50s. Top-line momentum accelerated significantly in Q3, with high single-digit growth in net written premiums, including strong broad-based growth in marine and healthcare, and double-digit growth in E&S.

`

Investment Portfolio and Capital Management:

Net investment income was exceptionally strong, increasing 27.5% from the prior year quarter to $117 million in Q3 2025. This reflects growth in the asset base from underwriting and investment activity, improved partnership results, higher reinvestment yields, and successful portfolio repositioning. The fixed maturity portfolio maintains a weighted average rating of A+ with 95% investment grade. Gross unrealized losses on fixed maturities improved by $230.5 million to $300.6 million at September 30, 2025, primarily due to lower interest rates and changes in credit spreads.

THG maintains a robust capital position. Book value per share increased approximately 7% sequentially and 21% year-to-date as of September 30, 2025. The company was active in share repurchases, buying back approximately 323,000 shares totaling $55 million between July and October 27, 2025, with $210 million remaining under its existing program. In August 2025, THG issued $500 million of 5.50% senior unsecured debentures, using a portion of the proceeds to repay maturing debt and intending to repay $375 million of senior notes due April 2026. Net cash provided by operating activities increased by $207 million to $799.9 million for the first nine months of 2025, underscoring strong liquidity.

Outlook and Strategic Trajectory

The Hanover Insurance Group is poised for continued strong performance, with management expressing confidence in its strategic direction and financial guidance for 2025. The company expects overall consolidated net written premium growth to be in the 6% to 7% range, with Specialty and Small Commercial anticipated to exceed this, while Personal Lines and Middle Market growth are projected to be below it. Net investment income is forecast to increase by 12% to 14% from 2024, driven by higher earned yields and increased cash flow. The expense ratio is expected to decrease to 30.5%, reflecting a return to its long-term improvement trend of 20 basis points per annum, following temporary spikes due to variable compensation tied to strong performance.

The combined ratio excluding catastrophes is guided to be in the range of 88.5% to 89.5% for 2025, an improvement from the 90% to 91% guide provided a year ago. This reflects anticipated margin improvements across Personal Lines and Core Commercial (driven by property), coupled with higher net investment income and expense ratio efficiencies. The effective tax rate is expected to approximate the statutory rate of 21%. The full-year catastrophe load is projected at 6.5%, with the fourth-quarter CAT load at 5.2%.

Management's confidence is rooted in the successful execution of its margin recapture strategy and catastrophe mitigation plans, which are now contributing to superior returns. Personal Lines is expected to achieve target profitability on an earned basis in 2025, with pricing remaining ahead of loss trends and PIF expansion anticipated in Q4 2025 in diversification states. In Core Commercial, liability pricing is expected to accelerate, and some improvement to the loss ratio is projected, driven by property. Specialty is set to be a significant driver of enterprise top-line expansion, leveraging its strong profitability and strategic investments.

Risks and Challenges

Despite a strong outlook, THG faces several pertinent risks. Market volatility and uncertainty in financial markets continue to affect investment values, with potential for increased realized and unrealized losses. Economic conditions, including labor markets, inflation, and geopolitical risks, could impact fixed-income investments and potentially increase defaults. Liability trends, particularly social inflation and the legal abuse environment, remain a concern, prompting THG to maintain vigilance and prudent reserving practices, including increased picks in commercial auto and umbrella. Catastrophe exposure, while mitigated by strategic actions and reinsurance, remains an inherent risk, with severe weather events posing a threat to underwriting results. Price competition, especially in certain property-oriented sectors and the monoline auto market, could pressure net premiums written and underwriting margins. Furthermore, while THG is investing heavily in technology, rapid advancements in digital innovation by competitors could pose a challenge if THG's pace of adoption or effectiveness lags. The company's reliance on independent agents, while a strength, also means its growth is tied to the health and strategic alignment of its distribution partners.

Conclusion

The Hanover Insurance Group stands as a compelling investment proposition, demonstrating a powerful blend of strategic foresight, operational excellence, and technological innovation. Its diversified portfolio, robust profitability, and disciplined capital management have positioned the company for sustained success in a dynamic P&C insurance market. The strategic repositioning of its Personal Lines and Core Commercial segments, coupled with the accelerating growth in Specialty, underscores a well-executed plan to enhance margins and mitigate risk. THG's significant investments in AI-powered platforms and workflow automation are not merely incremental improvements; they are foundational differentiators that enhance efficiency, agent experience, and underwriting precision, creating a durable competitive advantage.

With a clear outlook for continued margin expansion, driven by strong pricing, favorable loss trends, and increasing net investment income, THG is set to deliver enhanced shareholder value. While macro-economic uncertainties and competitive pressures persist, the company's proactive risk management, strong balance sheet, and agile business model provide a solid buffer. THG's commitment to its independent agency partners, combined with its technological leadership, ensures its relevance and growth potential. Investors should view THG as a resilient and strategically positioned insurer, capable of capitalizing on market opportunities and delivering consistent, profitable growth through its balanced portfolio and innovative approach.