Executive Summary / Key Takeaways

• Transformative Merger Fuels Strong Performance: Burke & Herbert Financial Services Corp. (BHRB) has successfully integrated Summit Financial Group, Inc., driving a significant 79.8% increase in net interest income and a 387.7% surge in net income for the first half of 2025, demonstrating the strategic benefits of enhanced scale and diversification.
• Robust Profitability and Margin Expansion: The post-merger entity exhibits improved profitability, with a tax-adjusted net interest margin expanding to 4.17% and a net profit margin of 21.20% (TTM), reflecting effective asset-liability management and higher-yielding acquired loans.
• Strategic Positioning in a Challenging CRE Market: Despite broader commercial real estate (CRE) sector headwinds, BHRB's diversified loan portfolio, robust underwriting standards, and proactive risk management position it to outperform, with a significant concentration in Virginia and a manageable exposure to office buildings.
• Solid Capital and Liquidity Profile: BHRB maintains a "well capitalized" status with ample liquidity, including $4.10 billion in unused borrowing capacity, providing a strong foundation for continued growth and resilience against market fluctuations, even as deposit costs face competitive pressures.
• Undervalued Opportunity with Sustainable Dividend: The company's stock trades at a discount to its historical price-to-tangible book value, offering an attractive entry point for investors seeking a regional banking play with improved fundamentals and a sustainable 3.46% dividend yield.

A Legacy Bank's Modern Transformation

Burke & Herbert Financial Services Corp. (NASDAQ:BHRB) stands as a testament to enduring community banking, tracing its roots back to 1852 as Burke & Herbert Bank & Trust Company. This institution holds the unique distinction of being the oldest continuously operating bank under its original name in the greater Washington, D.C. metropolitan area. For over a century and a half, BHRB has cultivated deep community ties, primarily serving Northern Virginia and West Virginia, a foundation that underpins its relationship-based banking model.

The company embarked on a significant structural evolution on October 1, 2022, forming a holding company, Burke & Herbert Financial Services Corp., to enhance strategic flexibility. This was followed by its election as a financial holding company in September 2023, expanding its regulatory purview. A pivotal moment arrived on May 3, 2024, with the transformative merger with Summit Financial Group, Inc. This acquisition was not merely an expansion; it was a strategic re-calibration, creating a more balanced and resilient bank with reduced unrealized losses and a more diversified loan portfolio.

Digital Capabilities: Enabling the Community Bank

In an increasingly digital financial landscape, BHRB leverages modern technology to enhance its community banking model. The company offers a comprehensive suite of digital banking services, including online and mobile banking, cash management solutions, and treasury management tools. These encompass enhanced reporting, automated clearing house (ACH) services, wire transfers, remote deposit capture, bill pay, lockbox services, and credit and debit card offerings.

These digital capabilities are not just features; they are essential enablers, allowing BHRB to deliver efficient, convenient services while maintaining its personalized, relationship-focused approach. While BHRB does not boast a proprietary "deep tech" differentiator akin to a specialized software firm, its robust digital infrastructure is critical for competitive parity and for enhancing customer experience, particularly for small businesses and commercial clients who increasingly rely on seamless digital interactions. This technological integration supports operational efficiency and helps BHRB extend its reach across its expanded five-state footprint, which now includes Delaware, Kentucky, Maryland, Virginia, and West Virginia, without sacrificing its local touch.

Competitive Landscape: A Regional Player Among Giants

BHRB operates within a dynamic banking sector, competing directly with a spectrum of institutions from national behemoths to other regional players. Its primary direct competitors include large national banks like Bank of America (BAC) and Wells Fargo (WFC), as well as significant regional-to-national banks such as PNC Financial Services (PNC), Capital One (COF), and Truist Financial (TFC).

BHRB differentiates itself through its deep regional expertise and community-centric approach, fostering strong customer loyalty through personalized services. This localized strategic adaptability allows it to effectively serve small businesses and local clients who often prioritize relationship banking over the standardized offerings of larger institutions. For instance, while Bank of America (BAC) and Wells Fargo (WFC) leverage extensive branch networks and advanced digital platforms for broader market reach, BHRB's strength lies in its ability to tailor solutions and provide more responsive support within its specific markets.

However, BHRB's smaller scale presents certain vulnerabilities. Larger competitors like BAC and PNC typically exhibit stronger revenue growth trends and higher profitability margins, benefiting from economies of scale and greater resources for innovation. BHRB's net profit margin of 21.20% (TTM) is competitive, but it generally trails the larger players in overall financial health, such as cash flow generation and return metrics, which are often bolstered by their diversified revenue streams and broader market penetration.

\
Capital One (COF), with its aggressive digital and consumer lending focus, highlights BHRB's potential lag in innovation speed and tech-driven efficiency. Truist (TFC), a direct regional competitor, also benefits from a larger post-merger scale, which can drive stronger cash flow and strategic execution. BHRB's competitive moat is built on its established community brand and regulatory licenses, which act as barriers to entry for new players and help it defend against rivals. However, its smaller size means it must continuously optimize its digital offerings and service delivery to remain competitive against rivals with deeper pockets and more advanced technological capabilities.

The Summit Merger: A Catalyst for Growth and Diversification

The merger with Summit Financial Group, Inc., completed on May 3, 2024, marked a pivotal strategic inflection point for BHRB. This transaction significantly expanded the company's geographic footprint and diversified its loan portfolio, integrating Summit's operations across Delaware, Kentucky, Maryland, Virginia, and West Virginia. The strategic rationale behind the merger was clear: to achieve greater scale, enhance market presence, and realize substantial synergies and cost savings.

The acquisition resulted in the recognition of $34.10 million in goodwill, primarily representing the anticipated synergies and cost savings from combining the two entities. Additionally, a core deposit intangible of $68.80 million was recognized, reflecting the value of long-term deposit relationships acquired, which is being amortized over an estimated weighted average life of 7.00 years using an accelerated method. The one-year period for fair value adjustments related to the acquisition expired during the second quarter of 2025, indicating the finalization of the accounting for this significant transaction. This merger has fundamentally reshaped BHRB's operational and financial profile, setting the stage for its current performance trajectory.

Financial Performance: Post-Merger Momentum

BHRB's financial results for the first half of 2025 vividly illustrate the positive impact of the Summit merger. Net income applicable to common shares surged to $56.60 million for the six months ended June 30, 2025, a remarkable $68.60 million increase compared to a net loss of $11.90 million in the prior-year period. This dramatic improvement is largely attributable to a full six months of combined income post-merger, contrasting with the prior year which bore the brunt of merger-related expenses and a one-time CECL Day 2 provision of $23.20 million for acquired non-PCD assets.

\

Net interest income, the company's primary revenue driver, increased by $65.30 million to $147.20 million for the first half of 2025, representing a substantial 79.8% growth. This was driven by the expanded asset base from the merger, higher rates on interest-earning assets, and increased accretion income from acquired loans and borrowings, which totaled $23.00 million. The tax-adjusted net interest margin expanded to 4.17% for the six months ended June 30, 2025, up from 3.56% in the prior year, underscoring effective asset-liability management. The yield on the taxable loan portfolio also improved to 6.93% from 6.72%, primarily due to the acquisition of higher-yielding loans.

\

Non-interest income also saw robust growth, increasing by $9.10 million, or 66.4%, to $22.90 million. This growth was broad-based across most categories, with income from company-owned life insurance rising by $2.70 million due to increased death proceeds, and bank debit and other card revenue increasing by $2.30 million from combined operations and higher customer activity. Non-interest expense, while increasing by $13.40 million (15.6%) to $99.00 million, reflects a full six months of combined operations, partially offset by realized merger cost savings. The efficiency ratio, a key measure of operational effectiveness, improved significantly to 58.18% for the six months ended June 30, 2025, from 89.49% in the prior year, highlighting the successful integration and synergy realization.

\

Asset Quality and Risk Management: Addressing Headwinds

BHRB maintains a proactive approach to asset quality and risk management, crucial in the current economic climate. The company's loan portfolio, net of allowance for credit losses (ACL), stood at $5.50 billion as of June 30, 2025, a decrease of $81.80 million from December 31, 2024. This reduction was primarily due to "the exiting of loans that do not align with the Company's desired risk profile," indicating a disciplined approach to portfolio management.

However, the commercial real estate (CRE) sector remains a significant area of focus. BHRB's exposure to CRE (excluding owner-occupied and acquisition, construction development) was $2.80 billion, representing 49.5% of its gross loan portfolio. Including owner-occupied and acquisition, construction development, total CRE exposure reached $3.70 billion, or 66.8% of total gross loans and 46.4% of total assets. While the CRE sector faces challenges from rising interest rates and vacancies, BHRB believes its "underwriting and monitoring standards for commercial real estate loans are sufficient to evaluate its loan portfolio and keep it from incurring significant losses." The largest concentration of CRE loans is in Virginia (approximately 47.4%), with a manageable 16.6% exposure to the office building/condo collateral type. The appointment of Robert V. "Cedar" Hintelmann, Jr. as Chief Credit Officer in March 2025, with his extensive credit risk management experience, further underscores the company's commitment to robust credit oversight.

Non-performing assets, including non-accrual loans and those 90 days past due, increased to $88.30 million at June 30, 2025, from $41.20 million at December 31, 2024. This rise is reflected in the allowance for credit losses as a percentage of non-performing loans, which decreased from 207.10% to 78.63% over the same period. This indicates a need for continued vigilance in managing credit quality.

Liquidity remains robust, with $4.10 billion in unused borrowing capacity from various sources. Total deposits decreased by $124.30 million, primarily due to a $112.70 million reduction in brokered deposits, reflecting management's strategic evaluation of non-core funding sources. The company's capital position is strong, with the Bank categorized as "well capitalized" under regulatory frameworks, and $293.60 million of retained earnings available for dividend declaration. BHRB actively manages interest rate risk, with simulations indicating a modest 2.70% change in projected income for a +200 basis point shift in interest rates, and an 8.10% change in Economic Value of Equity for the same scenario, suggesting a relatively balanced position.

Outlook and Strategic Imperatives

BHRB's forward trajectory is shaped by its post-merger integration, ongoing market dynamics, and strategic initiatives. The company's focus remains on organic deposit growth, consistent with its relationship-based strategy, while prudently managing brokered deposits. The recent authorization of a share repurchase program, allowing for up to $50.00 million in common stock purchases, signals management's confidence in the company's valuation and commitment to shareholder returns.

Legislative changes, such as the "One Big Beautiful Bill Act" signed on July 4, 2025, which allows for more favorable deductibility of certain business expenses, could positively impact BHRB's future tax obligations, though the company is still evaluating the full impact. While the CRE market presents ongoing challenges, potential tailwinds from falling interest rates in late 2024 and federal and private sector mandates for employees to return to offices could offer some relief, though the extent of this improvement remains uncertain. BHRB's "well-diversified, generally seasoned, manageable" loan portfolio is expected to "outperform the industry in terms of performance through the economic cycle."

Conclusion

Burke & Herbert Financial Services Corp. has successfully navigated a transformative merger, emerging as a larger, more diversified, and financially robust regional bank. The significant improvements in net interest income, net income, and efficiency ratios for the first half of 2025 underscore the effective integration of Summit Financial Group and the realization of anticipated synergies. While the commercial real estate sector and rising non-performing assets warrant close monitoring, BHRB's disciplined risk management, strong capital position, and ample liquidity provide a solid foundation.

The company's commitment to its community banking model, enhanced by digital capabilities, positions it to compete effectively against larger rivals by emphasizing personalized service and local expertise. With its stock trading at a discount to historical valuations and offering a sustainable dividend, BHRB presents a compelling investment thesis for those seeking exposure to a regional bank that has successfully executed a strategic expansion and is poised for sustained profitability in a dynamic market environment. The ongoing focus on operational efficiency, strategic loan portfolio management, and prudent capital allocation will be key determinants of its continued success.